The SCSS's National Advisory Board is made up of the following distinguished Catholic scholars:
| Stratford Caldecott | Rev. Francis J. Canavan, S.J., Ph.D. |
| Rev. Msgr. Eugene V. Clark, Ph.D. | Dr. Donald J. D'Elia, Co-Chairman Emeritus |
| Dr. William A. Donohue | Dr. Allan C. Carlson |
| Rev. Joseph Fessio, S.J., Ph.D. | Rev. Monsignor Michael J. Wrenn |
| Rev. Msgr. George P. Graham, Ph.D. | Rev. Benedict Groeschel, C.F.R., Ed.D. |
| Rev. Brian W. Harrison, O.S. | Rev. John F. Harvey, O.S.F.S., S.T.D. |
| Rev. Terence Henry, T.O.R. | Dr. James Hitchcock |
| Prof. Gerard V. Bradley, Esq. - Chairman | Rev. Robert J. Levis, Ph.D. |
| Dr. Warren H. Carroll | Prof. Mary Ann Glendon, Esq |
| Dr. Candace de Russy | Dr. Rupert J. Ederer |
| Dr. Timothy T. O'Donnell | Dr. Michael J. Healy |
| Rev. Michael Scanlan, T.O.R., J.D., Litt.D. | Dr. John M. Finnis |
| Dr. Alberto M. Piedra | Mr. James Likoudis |
| Dr. Johannes Stemmler | Dr. Peter V. Sampo |
| Dr. Joseph H. Hagan | Dr. Paul C. Vitz |
| Dean Bernard Dobranski, Esq. | Rev. Rodger Charles, S.J., D. Litt. |
| Dr. Dominic Aquila | Dr. Ronda Chervin |
|
Late members of our Board of Advisors |
|
| +Dr. Russell Kirk (d. 1994) | +Joseph Scottino, Ph.D. (d.1999) |
| Rev. Ronald Lawler, O.F.M. Cap., Ph.D. (d. 2003) | |
| +Frederick Wilhelmsen, Ph.D. (d.1996) | Rev. Msgr. George A. Kelly (d. 2005) |
The Bishops Advisory Board
| Anthony Cardinal Bevilacqua (Philadelphia) | Archbishop Charles J. Chaput, O.F.M. Cap. (Denver) |
| Edward M. Cardinal Egan (New York) | Archbishop Roberto O. Gonzalez (San Juan) |
| Archbishop Raymond L. Burke (St. Louis) | Bishop Thomas G. Doran (Rockford) |
| Bishop Norman McFarland (Emeritus, Orange) | Archbishop John J. Myers (Newark) |
| Archbishop George Cardinal Pell (Sydney, Australia) | Bishop James C. Timlin (Emeritus, Scranton) |
| Bishop Allen H. Vigneron (Oakland) | Bishop William F. Murphy (Rockville Centre) |
| Bishop Michael J. Sheridan (Colorado Springs) | Bishop Salvatore Cordileone |
| Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz (Lincoln) | |
|
Late members of the Bishops Board |
|
|
+John Cardinal O'Connor (New York) (d.2000) |
+Bishop Glennon Flavin (Lincoln) (d.1995) |
| +Bishop Austin Vaughan (Auxiliary, New York) (d.2000) | +Bishop James T. McHugh (d.2000) |